Page 23 - 23
P. 23

ARTICLE IN PRESS                                       1589

K. Lambeck et al. / Quaternary Science Reviews 23 (2004) 1567–1598

upper limit of the observed MIS 5.5 elevation and, at the     The North Adriatic offshore data, comprising peats
level of observational accuracy, the location is effec-    that are assumed to correspond to upper limits of sea
tively stable.                                             level, are consistent with the assumption of zero tectonic
                                                           movement with all observed data points lying above or
                                                           within the predicted range (cf. Fig. 4). Likewise, the
                                                           observed coastal and inland data points are in broad
                                                           agreement with the model values, assuming subsidence,
                                                           to within the uncertainties of both values (Fig. 8).
                                                           Possibly the assumed subsidence rate for Caorle Lagoon
                                                           is too high and that for Grado Lagoon is too low but the
                                                           data is insufficient to estimate improved subsidence rates
                                                           and we retain the assumed rates based on the sparse
                                                           evidence from the location of the Last Interglacial sea
                                                           levels across the region. The implication of these results
                                                           is that the subsidence caused by loading from the Po
                                                           River sediments is restricted to the inland and coastal
                                                           zone and that it is not important for the offshore sites.

                                                           6.1.3. Further comments on comparisons
                                                              One feature of the nominal eustatic sea-level function,

                                                           and one that has been retained in the present solution, is
                                                           that ocean volumes have continued to increase into Late
                                                           Holocene time and this has been attributed to the
                                                           continued melting of the Antarctic ice sheet after the
                                                           completion of the melting of the northern ice sheets
                                                           (Nakada and Lambeck, 1988). This is consistent with
                                                           the recent results by Stone et al. (2003) that demonstrate
                                                           that significant melting has occurred in at least one part
                                                           of Antarctica. The eustatic sea-level curve for this post-
                                                           northern hemisphere glacial period is therefore impor-
                                                           tant for constraining the total changes in ice volumes.
                                                           Most analyses have indicated that much of this decay
                                                           occurred before about 2000–3000 years ago (Lambeck,
                                                           2002) and this is consistent with the Italian evidence
                                                           (Fig. 9) that supports eustatic levels below present
                                                           values in the interval 7–5 ka BP but the present Italian
                                                           data is not sufficiently accurate to establish better
                                                           constraints on this function for the more recent interval.

                                                              Some of the comparisons indicate differences that
                                                           exceed the uncertainties associated with both the
                                                           observed and predicted sea-levels values and this may
                                                           point to either limitations of the tectonic values adopted
                                                           or to data problems. For most of these sites the
                                                           comparisons are based on one or two observations only

                                                           Fig. 6. Observed sea-level data, tectonically and isostatically cor-
                                                           rected, corresponding to the eustatic or ice-volume-equivalent sea level
                                                           function. (a) The ‘Italian’ solution. The data is grouped according to
                                                           whether they are terrestrial, marine or transitional indicators. The
                                                           dashed line illustrates the nominal eustatic function used in the model
                                                           corrections and the solid line illustrates the best estimate based on the
                                                           Italian data. (b) The ‘global’ solution based on data from Huon
                                                           Peninsula, Barbados, Tahiti, and New Zealand. The solid line
                                                           illustrates the ‘Italian’ solution and the dashed line the solution
                                                           inferred from the coral data (Lambeck et al., 2002). (c) The second
                                                           iteration Italian solution based on the revised eustatic sea-level
                                                           function from the combined global and Italian data sets.
   18   19   20   21   22   23   24   25   26   27   28